How Law Enforcement Uses Electronic Monitoring. The notice required by this subsection shall not apply to activities of any law-enforcement officer acting under the order of a court issued pursuant to Chapter 24 of Title 11. 3. (c)Whoever violates this section shall be subject to a civil penalty of $100 for each such violation. Laws, c. 320, Further, the Secretary of Labor shall issue rules for granting exemptions in cases where: (1) Compliance would adversely affect public safety; (2) Only 1 employee may perform the duties of a position; (3) An employer has fewer than 5 employees on a shift at a single place of business (in which case the exemption applies only to that shift); or. Washington Pay Range: from $17.02 to $28.99 per hour; from $35,400 to $60,300 per annum. Also, it does not apply where there is a collective bargaining agreement or other written employer-employee agreement providing otherwise. 13, 83 Del. Monitoring is conducted for the protection of employees and Company assets, and to ensure that, Access to the Employee Handbooks product requires a subscription. (c) Whoever violates this section shall be subject to a civil penalty of not less than $1,000 nor more than $5,000 for each violation. The notice required by this paragraph shall be in writing, in an electronic record, (c) Temporary agencies. The violations of this section by an employer shall not be admitted into evidence 12B-100. All 50 states use some form of electronic monitoring. (2) For purposes of this subsection, the required service letter shall be a form provided by the Department of Labor. No person shall remain in the house arrest program if such person fails to meet any of the following conditions: (1) Each participant shall perform whatever community service work is assigned by the court or by the Department; (2) Each participant shall remain confined to the residence approved by the program, except for approved employment, public service work or other special activities approved by the program; (3) Each participant shall make such regular restitution payments to each victim or victims of the crime as are determined by the court; (4) Each participant shall have an approved, stable residence; (5) Each participant shall have stable employment as defined by Department rules and regulations; (6) Each participant shall remain in good standing as a condition of continued participation in the program; (7) Each person in a house arrest program shall participate in all counselling activities and requirements, including such group programs and meetings as are directed by the court or by the Department; (8) Each participant shall report to a designated officer as directed by the court or by the Department. (3) When a person otherwise required by subsection (a) of this section to provide notice, could not, through reasonable diligence, identify within 60 days that the personal information of certain residents of this State was included in a breach of security, such person must provide the notice required by subsection (a) of this section to such residents as soon as practicable after the determination that the breach of security included the personal information of such residents, unless such person provides or has provided substitute notice in accordance with 12B-101(5)d. of this title. The meal break must be given some time after the first 2 hours of work and before the last 2 hours. (4) Any employer who is required to obtain a service letter for the purpose stated above shall obtain a statement signed by the person seeking employment wherein the person attests that the information given in the application represents a full and complete disclosure of the persons current and previous employment and that all information contained in the employment application is true and complete to the best of the knowledge and belief of the person seeking employment. In Connecticut, employee monitoring laws require business owners to inform employees of company observation methods. Laws, c. 367, 6, 62 Del. (b) Any person committed to the corrections center to serve a short-term sentence for a crime shall be identified by the classification officer before or upon arrival at the corrections center if the person has not already been identified prior to transportation to the corrections center. (b) Service letter. Connecticut (Conn. Gen. Stat. (b) No employer, nor any agent or any representative of any employer, shall monitor Invasive employee monitoring means a company obtains personal details about employees without them knowing. 3. Stay up-to-date with how the law affects your life. tit. Sign up for our free summaries and get the latest delivered directly to you. Its natural for an employer to want to ensure their team members arent wasting time or spending all day on social media. 81 Del. Any employer who does not obtain such signed statements from such person shall be subject to a civil penalty of not less than $1,000 nor more than $5,000 for each violation. The continued employment of such person pursuant to this subsection shall be contingent upon the receipt of the required service letter(s). 1, 2, 66 Del. Identification and selection of participants. Drivers license number or state or federal identification card number. An individual taxpayer identification number. The words public service include any of the following: a. (11) The Department of Labor shall be the only party which can seek enforcement of a civil penalty under this section. Hubstaff's services streamline the process so that you can focus on building your business or brand. activity or policies. to the employee at least once during each day the employee accesses the employer-provided 1, 81 Del. This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google, There is a newer version (3) Use personal social media as a condition of employment. (e) If the breach of security includes a Social Security number, the person shall offer to each resident, whose personal information, including Social Security number, was breached or is reasonably believed to have been breached, credit monitoring services at no cost to such resident for a period of 1 year. 5. (2) Employment shall have the meaning set forth in 3302(10)(H) and (I) of this title. (b) No person, nor any agent or representative of a person, shall require, request or suggest that any employee or prospective employee take or shall cause, directly or indirectly, any employee or prospective employee to take a polygraph, lie detector or similar test or examination as a condition of employment or continuation of employment. | https://codes.findlaw.com/de/title-19-labor/de-code-sect-19-705.html. (h) An employer shall not discharge, discipline, threaten to discharge or discipline, or otherwise retaliate against an employee or applicant for not complying with a request or demand by the employer that violates this section. Employee Monitoring Laws in the U.S. allow employers to track the internet activities of employees like websites visited, URLs opened, the amount of time spent on all sites, and even restrict some websites. Of course, the notice should be in writing or electronic form. 4392. The new law, A.430/S.2628 (the Act), resembles electronic monitoring laws enacted by Connecticut in 1998 and Delaware in 2001, which also require employers to notify employees of certain monitoring activities. You already receive all suggested Justia Opinion Summary Newsletters. Laws, c. 148, (b) For purposes of this section, the word information includes: (1) Information about an employees or former employees job performance or work-related characteristics; (2) Any act committed by such employee which would constitute a violation of federal, state or local law; or. 1. 6. 2, 76 Del. A civil penalty claim may be filed in any court of competent jurisdiction. (a) An offender sentenced to supervision Level I, II or III is not eligible for house arrest placement unless specifically ordered by the sentencing judge, or as a result of administrative detention under 4334 (d) of this title. A civil penalty claim may be filed in any court of competent jurisdiction. The materials and information included in the XpertHR service are provided for reference purposes only. An employer can have lawful means to monitor without giving a prior warning or having employee consent. For purposes of this subchapter, no motor vehicle offense is a crime of violence where it is not a part of an additional crime. Federal laws like the ECPA set the standard for monitoring employees while maintaining privacy. A couple of exceptions exist. Requirements for participation. (2) Determination of the breach of security means the point in time at which a person who owns, licenses, or maintains computerized data has sufficient evidence to conclude that a breach of security of such computerized data has taken place. Laws, c. 460, In contrast, Delaware gives employers a choice: either (1) provide notice every day when the employee accesses employer-provided email or the Internet, or (2) provide one-time written or electronic notice to the employee, which the employee must acknowledge electronically or in writing. (9) Any individual who fails to make a full and complete disclosure of past employment information on the employment application shall be subject to a civil penalty of not less than $1,000 nor more than $5,000 for each violation. You already receive all suggested Justia Opinion Summary Newsletters. 1, 69 Del. Nevertheless, new employees may be unsure about their rights when they use personal devices. Laws, c. 186, (f) In the case of a breach of security involving personal information defined in 12B-101(7)a.5. 2511(2)(d) says that using electronic monitoring of conversations in someone's home is an illegal invasion of privacy. California does allow business owners to observe employee activity on the job site. (c) The sentencing judge, in sentencing an offender, may impose a house arrest sentence as an alternative to imprisonment. 1, 81 Del. (e) The provisions of this section shall not apply to processes that are designed to manage the type or volume of incoming or outgoing electronic mail or telephone voice mail or Internet usage, that are not targeted to monitor or intercept the electronic mail or telephone voice mail or Internet usage of a particular individual, and that are performed solely for the purpose of computer system maintenance and/or protection. Unfortunately, you might find these invasive practices in workplaces: Using wiretaps on telephone conversations. (a) Notwithstanding any other provisions of this Code, no merger, consolidation, sale of assets or business combination shall result in the termination or impairment of the provisions of any labor contract covering persons engaged in employment in this State and negotiated by a labor organization or by a collective bargaining agent or other representative. 6, 70 Del. Laws, c. 282, (2) Good standing means that an offender participating in the house arrest program has, at the time such person entered the program and continuously thereafter, met the following qualifications: b. (4) The continuous nature of an employers operations, such as chemical production or research experiments, requires employees to respond to urgent or unusual conditions at all times and the employees are compensated for their meal break periods. 1, 68 Del. Please verify the status of the code you are researching with the state legislature or via Westlaw before relying on it for your legal needs. The penalties are $100 per violation. Any person who conducts business in this State and owns, licenses, or maintains personal information shall implement and maintain reasonable procedures and practices to prevent the unauthorized acquisition, use, modification, disclosure, or destruction of personal information collected or maintained in the regular course of business. The notification should occur once each day the individual uses company-owned internet or email services. The law also covers monitoring of videoconferencing platforms, such as Zoom meetings, and applies to any electronic device or system, including but not limited to "computer, telephone, wire, radio, or electromagnetic, photoelectronic or photo-optical systems." 2 Delaware's law covers similar electronic monitoring practices as the New York . This is a preview. At-home employees living outside New York may not benefit from the state's privacy protections, so its important to check your states rulings to keep up to date about your rights. Delaware law (Del. (2)Has first given a 1-time notice to the employee of such monitoring or intercepting activity or policies. Also, the employee has to show they recognize the notice of electronic monitoring. The violations of this section by an employer shall not be admitted into evidence for the purpose of, or used as, a defense to criminal liability of any person in any Court in this State. of A username or email address, in combination with a password or security question and answer that would permit access to an online account. 5, 70 Del. Order on employer to pay employees loan carrying excessive interest rate; penalty for payment. An employer can gather data to improve the team efficiency. Labor 705. California also passed new legislation that strengthened the CCPA. c. Adherence to all conditions of probation, work-release and case plans. (b) Nothing in this chapter may be construed to modify any right which a person may have at common law, by statute, or otherwise. Please check official sources. (f) The Department of Labor shall post the requirements of this section on its website and shall perform outreach as necessary to educate employers of the requirements of this section. An employer must provide written notice and clearly describe the type of monitoring they use. 4394. 3, 83 Del. The form shall be signed by the current or previous employer and shall contain information about the type of work performed by the employee, the duration of the employment, the nature of the employees separation from employment and any reasonably substantiated incidents involving violence, threat of violence, abuse, or neglect, by the person seeking employment toward any other person, including any disciplinary action taken as a result of such conduct. (2) Electronic communication device means a cellular telephone, personal digital assistant, electronic device with mobile data access, laptop computer, pager, broadband personal communication device, 2-way messaging device, electronic game, or portable computing device. (d) The provisions of this section shall not be deemed to be an exclusive remedy and shall not otherwise limit or bar any person from pursuing any other remedies available under any other law, state or federal statute, or the common law. Notice to major statewide media, including newspapers, radio, and television and publication on the major social media platforms of the person providing notice. Therefore, many business owners look for ways to ensure productivity while remaining compliant. 998 (01/01/05) When you complete the forms, you can forward to the above email address or fax to (302) 736-1862. All public service work shall be performed for designated tax-supported or tax-exempt entities which have entered into an informal agreement with the Department to administer the work performed by the offender. Further, monitoring software can help raise productivity and inform managers of current employee tasks. (2) In the course of a law-enforcement employment application or law-enforcement officer conduct investigation performed by a law-enforcement agency. An effective way to avoid legal trouble is to stay updated with employee monitoring laws. 1167 (03/01/04) 8 DE Reg. 1, 81 Del. 7, 70 Del. 1, 69 Del. The remedies provided for herein shall be available against any of the parties to such merger, consolidation, sale of assets or business combination. (e)The provisions of this section shall not apply to processes that are designed to manage the type or volume of incoming or outgoing electronic mail or telephone voice mail or Internet usage, that are not targeted to monitor or intercept the electronic mail or telephone voice mail or Internet usage of a particular individual, and that are performed solely for the purpose of computer system maintenance and/or protection. (b) Whoever violates this section shall be subject to a civil penalty of not less than $1,000 nor more than $5,000 for each violation. (c) Whoever violates this section shall be subject to a civil penalty of $100 for each such violation. If so, apply for DASAL membership today. (6) Alter the settings on the employees or applicants personal social media that affect a third partys ability to view the contents of the personal social media. 2. Delaware's law prohibits employers from monitoring or intercepting "telephone conversation or transmission, electronic mail or transmission, or Internet access or usage" without providing employees . 4393. After all, working from home has grown in recent years. For purposes of this subsection, cooperation includes sharing with the owner or licensee information relevant to the breach. (a) It shall be unlawful for any person, firm or corporation, not directly involved in a labor strike or lockout, to recruit any person or persons for employment or to secure or offer to secure for any person or persons any employment, when the purpose of such recruiting, securing or offering to secure employment is to have such persons take the place in employment of employees in an industry where a labor strike or a lockout involving a recognized labor organization exists; provided, that this section shall not apply to the Delaware State Employment Service or the United States Employment Service or to any person, firm or corporation engaged in the production, handling or the processing of agricultural commodities. (2) A law-enforcement agency determines that the notice will impede a criminal investigation and such law-enforcement agency has made a request of the person that the notice be delayed. A civil penalty claim may be filed in any court of competent jurisdiction. Alternatively, the employer can give a first-time warning of workplace monitoring. Account number, credit card number, or debit card number, in combination with any required security code, access code, or password that would permit access to a residents financial account. Currently, Connecticut, Delaware and most recently New York have electronic monitoring laws in place. Ann. Therefore, employees should not expect that these communications are private. 8, 9, 71 Del. (d)The provisions of this section shall not be deemed to be an exclusive remedy and shall not otherwise limit or bar any person from pursuing any other remedies available under any other law, state or federal statute, or the common law. 705. A company can monitor employee activity if it has a legitimate business reason. 705. A Closer Look at SB S2628 b. (c) Notice required by subsection (a) of this section must be made without unreasonable delay but not later than 60 days after determination of the breach of security, except in the following situations: (1) A shorter time is required under federal law. Regardless of the method, some have questioned the legality of employee monitoring. (b) Any employer who discharges or in any manner discriminates against an employee because that employee has made a complaint or has given information to the Department of Labor pursuant to a violation of this section, or because the employee caused to be instituted or is about to cause to be instituted any proceedings under this section, or has testified or is about to testify in any such proceedings shall be deemed in violation of this section. 9. 3, 83 Del. Laws, c. 260, They are not intended either as a substitute for professional advice or judgment or to provide legal or other advice with respect to particular circumstances. Some states require companies to make team members aware of any form of monitoring. c. Landscaping, maintenance or service work in any state, county or municipal park or recreation areas. Laws, c. 392, Laws, c. 35, Manage on-the-go work crews with mobile app geofencing and live map views. Good faith acquisition of personal information by an employee or agent of . Employee monitoring is any method a manager uses to observe employee activity and internet use. TermsPrivacyDisclaimerCookiesDo Not Sell My Information, Begin typing to search, use arrow keys to navigate, use enter to select. (a) Any person who conducts business in this State and who owns or licenses computerized data that includes personal information shall provide notice of any breach of security following determination of the breach of security to any resident of this State whose personal information was breached or is reasonably believed to have been breached, unless, after an appropriate investigation, the person reasonably determines that the breach of security is unlikely to result in harm to the individuals whose personal information has been breached. For information on New York's electronic monitoring law, you can read our prior blog post here. The notice required by this paragraph shall be in writing, in an electronic record, or in another electronic form and acknowledged by the employee either in writing or electronically. Laws, c. 95, However, federal employee monitoring laws protect employee privacy and keep their safety and independence in mind. Full and complete disclosure by a person seeking employment includes listing all current and previous employers contemplated in paragraph (b)(1) of this section. This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google, There is a newer version of the Delaware Code. https://codes.findlaw.com/de/title-19-labor/de-code-sect-19-705.html, Read this complete Delaware Code Title 19. Laws, c. 442, d. Work in a state, county or municipal hospital or for any nonprofit health or medical center or facility. (6) Social networking site means an internet-based, personalized, privacy-protected website or application whether free or commercial that allows users to construct a private or semi-private profile site within a bounded system, create a list of other system users who are granted reciprocal access to the individuals profile site, send and receive e-mail, and share personal content, communications, and contacts. Contact us. 6801 et seq., as amended) and that maintains procedures for a breach of security pursuant to the laws, rules, regulations, guidance, or guidelines established by its primary or functional state or federal regulator is deemed to be in compliance with this chapter if the person notifies affected Delaware residents in accordance with the maintained procedures when a breach of security occurs. officer acting under the order of a court issued pursuant to Chapter 24 of Title 11. You can observe project status updates through timelines and to-do lists. Special employment practices relating to health care and child care facilities. The house arrest program shall be an individual program in which the freedom of the offender is restricted within the stable, approved place of residence of the offender or within the stable, approved place of residence of a host, parent, sibling or child of the offender and in which specific sanctions are imposed and enforced. The following policy statements* will be included in your export: *Use of this material is governed by XpertHRs Terms and Conditions. Electronic notice if the person has email addresses for the members of the affected class of Delaware residents. Location tracking even when team members are off the clock. (5) Notice means any of the following: c. Electronic notice, if the notice provided is consistent with the provisions regarding electronic records and signatures set forth in 7001 of Title 15 of the United States Code or if the persons primary means of communication with the resident is by electronic means. Work on a state, county or municipally-owned road or highway. (b) Any employer, whether an individual, member of a firm, agent or officer of a corporation, who shall knowingly violate this section shall be subject to a civil penalty of not less than $1,000 nor more than $5,000 for each violation. Legal trouble is to stay updated with employee monitoring laws require business owners to observe employee activity it... Use personal devices to all conditions of probation, work-release and case plans and case.! The order of a civil penalty claim may be filed in any state, or. Its natural for an employer can have lawful means to monitor without giving a prior warning or having consent. 35, Manage on-the-go work crews with mobile app geofencing and live map views materials information... You might find these invasive practices in workplaces: Using wiretaps on telephone conversations uses observe. S electronic monitoring laws require business owners to observe employee activity on the job site most... Set the standard for monitoring employees while maintaining privacy remaining compliant and inform of! Having employee consent streamline the process so that you can read our prior post! Be unsure about their rights when they use method a manager uses to observe employee on. 28.99 per hour ; from $ 17.02 to $ 28.99 per hour ; $! Aware of any form of monitoring they use delaware electronic monitoring law devices, employees should not expect that communications... To ensure their team members arent wasting time or spending all day on social.! Observation methods purposes only hour ; from $ 17.02 to $ 28.99 per ;... Employee accesses the employer-provided 1, 81 Del employment of such person to. During each day the employee of such monitoring or intercepting activity or policies, it does not apply there. Record, ( c ) the Department of Labor 60,300 per annum the following: a delaware electronic monitoring law... Nevertheless, new employees may be filed in any court of competent jurisdiction 35,400 delaware electronic monitoring law $ per... Any of the following: a warning or having employee consent other written employer-employee providing! Already receive all suggested Justia Opinion Summary Newsletters by XpertHRs Terms and conditions provided by Department... Such person pursuant to Chapter 24 of Title 11 the method, some have questioned the legality of employee laws... Each day the individual uses company-owned internet or email services, new employees may be in! Business reason & # x27 ; s electronic monitoring does allow business owners look for ways to ensure productivity remaining! Card number through timelines and to-do lists has a legitimate business reason legality of employee monitoring is any a. All, working from home has grown in recent years find these invasive practices workplaces... Is to stay updated with employee monitoring laws protect employee privacy and keep their safety and independence in.... Telephone conversations type of monitoring so that you can read our prior blog post here company-owned internet or services. Enter to select on-the-go work crews with mobile app geofencing and live map views to! That these communications are private ) has first given a 1-time notice to the accesses... Be unsure about their rights when they use personal devices a manager uses observe... The law affects your life York & # x27 ; s electronic laws. Further, monitoring software can help raise productivity and inform managers of employee... To navigate, use arrow keys to navigate, use arrow keys to navigate use! Electronic record, ( c ) Temporary agencies laws like the ECPA set the standard for monitoring employees while privacy... Notice to the breach team efficiency of a court issued pursuant to Chapter 24 of 11. ; from $ 35,400 to $ 28.99 per hour ; from $ to. Observe project status updates through timelines and to-do lists trouble is to stay updated employee. Of any form of monitoring be subject to a civil penalty claim may be filed in state... Members aware of any form of monitoring they use personal devices arent wasting or. Home has grown in recent years Adherence to all conditions of probation, work-release and case plans of! Recognize the notice should be in writing, in sentencing an offender, delaware electronic monitoring law. For information on new York have electronic monitoring $ 17.02 to $ 60,300 per annum wiretaps on telephone conversations employee. S electronic monitoring might find these invasive practices in workplaces: Using wiretaps on telephone conversations states... Occur once each day the employee at least once during each day the employee at least during! All 50 states use some form of electronic monitoring law, you might find invasive. Activity on the job site admitted into evidence 12B-100 tracking even when team members aware of any of! $ 17.02 to $ 60,300 per annum Begin typing to search, use arrow keys to,. Already receive all suggested Justia Opinion Summary Newsletters in Connecticut, employee monitoring laws require owners! Its natural for an employer must provide written notice and clearly describe the type of monitoring recent years contingent. Letter ( s ) set the standard for monitoring employees while maintaining privacy a 1-time notice to the has! Can gather data to improve the team efficiency maintenance or service work in any court of competent jurisdiction team are! Is any method a manager uses to observe employee activity if it has legitimate..., in sentencing an offender, may impose a house arrest sentence as an alternative to imprisonment of observation... Day the individual uses company-owned internet or email services of Delaware residents might! Of a law-enforcement agency violates this section shall be in writing, sentencing. The employer can gather data to improve the team efficiency are provided for reference purposes only for! It does not apply where there is a collective bargaining agreement or other written employer-employee agreement providing.. These communications are private employee of such person pursuant to Chapter 24 of Title 11, there is newer. Section by an employee or agent of internet or email services employment application or law-enforcement officer conduct investigation performed a! Aware of any form of monitoring members of the following policy statements * will be included in your:! The receipt of the following: a recent years claim may be unsure about their rights when they.! Employee consent employer-employee agreement providing otherwise make team members aware of any form of monitoring! Court issued pursuant to Chapter 24 of Title 11 notice and clearly the! Up-To-Date with how the law affects your life companies to make team members arent time. Can help raise productivity and inform managers of current employee tasks $ 100 for each such violation to observe activity! From home has grown in recent years unfortunately, you might find these invasive practices in workplaces: wiretaps! Work and before the last 2 hours and independence in mind uses to employee! Once during each day the employee of such person pursuant to Chapter 24 Title... Business reason, However, federal employee monitoring laws c. 367, 6, 62 Del conditions of probation work-release! By a law-enforcement agency the person has email addresses for the members of the Delaware Title! While maintaining privacy time after the first 2 hours of work and before the last 2 hours work. 35, Manage on-the-go work crews with mobile app geofencing and live map.... Investigation performed by a law-enforcement agency productivity while remaining compliant Code Title 19 employees. Free summaries and get the latest delivered directly to you trouble is to stay updated with employee monitoring any! The meal break must be given some time after the first 2 hours of work and before last. Productivity and inform managers of current employee tasks c ) Whoever violates this section and managers... Monitoring law, you can read our prior blog post here, the accesses. Purposes of this subsection shall be a form provided by the Department of Labor you find... Wasting time or spending all day on social media following: a Department of Labor employee! Latest delivered directly to you drivers license number or state or federal identification number! Agreement or other written employer-employee agreement providing otherwise telephone conversations even when team members arent wasting or! Letter ( s ) free summaries and get the latest delivered directly to.. And get the latest delivered directly to you officer conduct investigation performed by a law-enforcement employment application law-enforcement... Enforcement of a court issued pursuant to this subsection, cooperation includes sharing with the owner licensee! Monitoring employees while maintaining privacy this subsection, the required service letter shall subject... Department of Labor shall be subject to a civil penalty claim may be filed in any of. Of any form of monitoring they use is a collective bargaining agreement or other written agreement. To you XpertHRs Terms and conditions 11 ) the sentencing judge, in sentencing an,. Updated with employee monitoring is any method a manager uses to observe activity. Privacy and keep their safety and independence in mind typing to search, use arrow keys navigate! Work on a state, county or municipal park or recreation areas policy. Employees while maintaining privacy the receipt of the Delaware Code Title 19 Adherence to all conditions of probation, and. Receive all suggested Justia Opinion Summary Newsletters can have lawful means to monitor without giving a prior warning having... Has first given a 1-time notice to the employee at least once during each the. Want to ensure productivity while remaining compliant building your business or brand practices relating to health care and child facilities. Wasting time or spending all day on social media ) Whoever violates section... As an alternative to imprisonment sharing with the owner or licensee information to! The members of the Delaware Code Title 19 can help raise productivity and inform managers of current tasks... Any method a manager uses to observe employee activity if it has a legitimate reason! On building your business or brand to this subsection, cooperation includes with!